Javed Akhtar Supports Mohammed Shami Amid Controversy Over Fasting During Ramzan
On March 8, 2023, renowned poet and lyricist Javed Akhtar publicly expressed his support for Indian cricketer Mohammed Shami, who has recently found himself at the center of a heated controversy. The uproar began when Maulana Shahabuddin Razvi Bareilvi, the President of the All India Muslim Jamaat, labeled Shami "a criminal" for not observing ‘Roza’ (fasting) during the holy month of Ramzan. This statement sparked widespread debate about the intersection of sports, religion, and personal choice.
The Incident That Sparked Outrage
The controversy erupted after Shami was seen drinking an energy drink during a match between India and Australia at the Champions Trophy 2025 in Dubai. The sight of the Indian pacer hydrating himself in the sweltering heat led to backlash from certain quarters, particularly from Bareilvi, who criticized Shami for not adhering to the fasting practices that many Muslims observe during Ramzan.
In his remarks, Bareilvi stated, "By not keeping ‘Roza’, he has committed a crime. He should not do this. In the eyes of Shariat, he is a criminal. He will have to answer God." He emphasized that fasting is a compulsory duty for healthy individuals, and Shami’s actions could send a negative message to the public.
Javed Akhtar’s Response
In a show of solidarity, Javed Akhtar took to Twitter to defend Shami against the backlash. He urged the cricketer to disregard the opinions of those who criticize him for drinking water during a match. Akhtar’s tweet read, "Shami saheb, don’t give a damn to those reactionary bigoted idiots who have any problem with your drinking water in a burning afternoon at a cricket field in Dubai. It is none of their business. You are one of the great Indian team that is making us all proud. My best wishes to you and our whole team."
Akhtar’s words resonated with many, highlighting the importance of personal choice and the need to separate individual beliefs from public performance, especially in the realm of sports.
Support from Family and Fans
Shami’s cousin, Mumtaz, also came forward to defend him, emphasizing that the cricketer is representing the country and should not be subjected to such criticism. Mumtaz pointed out that many athletes, including players from other countries, often do not observe fasting while competing. He described the backlash as "shameful" and encouraged Shami to focus on his game rather than the negative comments.
Shami’s Performance Amidst Controversy
Despite the surrounding controversy, Mohammed Shami has continued to perform exceptionally well on the field. In the ongoing Champions Trophy, he has emerged as a key player for the Indian team, boasting impressive figures of 3/48 in 10 overs during the match against Australia. With a total of eight wickets in four matches at an average of 19.88, Shami has climbed to the second spot among the highest wicket-takers in the tournament, showcasing his talent and dedication to the sport.
The Significance of Ramzan
Ramzan, the ninth month of the Islamic lunar calendar, holds immense significance for Muslims around the world. It is a time for fasting, prayer, and reflection, with ‘Roza’ being one of the five pillars of Islam. Observing fasting from dawn until sunset is seen as a means of spiritual growth, self-discipline, and community solidarity. However, the expectations surrounding fasting can sometimes clash with the realities of modern life, particularly for those in demanding professions like sports.
A Broader Discussion on Personal Choices
The controversy surrounding Mohammed Shami raises important questions about personal choices in the context of public life. Athletes often face immense pressure to perform, and the expectations placed upon them can sometimes conflict with their personal beliefs and practices. The support from figures like Javed Akhtar and family members like Mumtaz underscores the need for understanding and compassion in discussions about faith and professional commitments.
As the debate continues, it serves as a reminder of the complexities that arise when individual beliefs intersect with public expectations, particularly in a diverse and multifaceted society like India.
