Coroner Demands Urgent Regulation of Maternity Services Following Death of Steve Bruce’s Grandson
A coroner has called for immediate action regarding the unregulated maternity services sector after the tragic death of Steve Bruce’s four-month-old grandson, Madison Bruce-Smith, in October 2024. The inquest revealed that Madison died after being placed to sleep on his stomach, a practice contrary to established safety guidelines.
Details of the Incident
Madison was found unresponsive at his family home in Bowdon, Trafford, on October 18, 2024, by his father, Matt Smith, a former Leeds United forward. The inquest heard that the infant’s sleeping position was advised by a woman claiming to be a maternity nurse, despite her lack of formal medical qualifications.
Coroner Ms. Mutch indicated that she would be issuing a report to the health secretary advocating for the regulation of maternity nurses and the companies providing maternity services. She emphasized the need for oversight in an industry where individuals may lack the necessary training and experience.
Concerns Over Unregulated Services
The coroner noted that the demand for maternity services is evident among parents seeking support. However, she highlighted the risks associated with employing unqualified individuals. “The unregulated advice given by maternity nurses and maternity services puts children at risk,” Ms. Mutch stated.
In a statement, Matt and Amy Smith expressed their devastation over Madison’s death, describing it as “utterly excruciating.” They lamented their decision to follow the advice of Eva Clements, the maternity nurse, whom they believed to be qualified and experienced. They pointed out that the maternity practitioner industry lacks regulation, allowing anyone to claim such titles without any formal training or oversight.
The Role of Maternity Nurse
The inquest revealed that Clements had no formal nursing or midwifery training. She had advised the Smiths that she had successfully put her own children to sleep on their stomachs. Despite the couple’s concerns about Madison’s sleeping position, Clements reassured them, suggesting they “best leave him.”
Detective Chief Inspector Matthew Dixon noted that both Clements and Ruth Asare, who runs Ruthie Maternity Services, referred to themselves as maternity nurses, which could mislead parents about their qualifications. As reported by www.mirror.co.uk, the court was informed that UK medical guidelines recommend that babies should sleep on their backs, a practice that has been in place for over 25 years.
Legal and Regulatory Implications
Following Madison’s death, police investigated Clements for neglect but concluded that the threshold for criminal charges was not met. The court found it was not illegal to place a child on their stomach, nor could it be established that Clements had deliberately intended to harm Madison.
Ms. Mutch criticized the use of the term “maternity nurse” as “incredibly misleading.” She stated that the lack of regulation in the industry poses significant risks to infants. The Smiths emphasized that without regulatory measures, similar tragedies could occur, endangering other families.
The Need for Change
The Smiths reiterated their belief that Madison died in a regulatory vacuum, urging for immediate reforms to ensure that individuals caring for infants possess the necessary qualifications and oversight. They expressed their frustration over the misleading language that suggests professionalism in an unregulated industry.
The inquest highlighted the need for a structured framework to prevent unqualified individuals from providing care to vulnerable infants. The Smiths’ experience serves as a cautionary tale for other parents seeking support in the maternity services sector.
Follow the latest developments and breaking updates in the Latest News section.
Published on 2026-03-23 23:28:00 • By Editorial Desk
